TBR Audits

Methodology and independence

A TBR audit asks one question: can a client, a counterparty or an investor rely on this firm? We answer it with evidence: registers checked at source, accounts opened and funded, withdrawals made, documents read. This page sets out exactly how.

The seven pillars

Every audit scores the same seven pillars, from 0 to 100, so grades can be compared across firms. The overall score is the weighted average; the percentages show each pillar's share of a full score.

  1. 01

    Regulation & Licensing 19%

    Licences held, matched against regulator registers, and the entity a client actually contracts with.

  2. 02

    Corporate Structure & Ownership 14%

    Group structure, beneficial ownership, audited accounts and capital adequacy.

  3. 03

    Client Money & Payouts 19%

    Segregation, banking partners, withdrawal and payout times tested with live accounts.

  4. 04

    Execution & Pricing 19%

    Spreads, slippage and fill quality measured against the firm’s published figures.

  5. 05

    Conduct & Disclosure 14%

    Marketing claims, terms, risk disclosure and complaint handling.

  6. 06

    Operational Resilience 10%

    Uptime, security controls, incident history and key-person dependence.

  7. 07

    People & Community 5%

    Workplace standards and community contribution, from public evidence: Great Place to Work certification and documented social programmes.

Where a pillar does not apply (client money at a software vendor that never holds it), it is marked not applicable and its weight is spread across the others in proportion.

The grade scale

GradeScoreMeaning
AAA80 to 100Exceptional
AA70 to 79Very strong
A60 to 69Strong
BBB50 to 59Adequate
BB40 to 49Weak in places
B30 to 39Material weaknesses
C0 to 29Serious concerns

The process

  1. Scoping. The audit team sets which entities, products and jurisdictions are in scope; Unita Media, which handles audit sales for TBR, agrees the fee and contract with the firm. Nothing about the result is agreed.
  2. Evidence request. The firm supplies licences, group structure, audited accounts, banking and safeguarding arrangements, policies and complaint data.
  3. Independent verification. We check every licence on the regulator's own register, search enforcement records, and corroborate ownership from public filings.
  4. Live testing. Our trading experts open and fund real accounts, trade, and withdraw, measuring execution, pricing and payout times against the firm's own published figures.
  5. Draft and right of reply. The firm sees the draft to correct factual errors only. It may publish a response alongside the report.
  6. Publication. The report, grade and badge are published in the registry, valid for 12 months.

Independence

A firm can commission and pay for its own audit. That is a conflict, and these rules exist to manage it in the open. Desk audits, carried out on our own initiative from public sources, are not paid for by anyone.

  • A firewall between sales and grading. Audits, advertising and partnerships are sold and managed by Unita Media, which handles TBR's commercial relationships. The people who audit, grade and score never discuss fees, contracts or partnerships, and have no commercial contact with any firm: all of it goes through Unita Media. Their only contact with a firm is about the audit itself, meaning evidence, factual accuracy and findings. The people who sell have no say in findings, grades, scores or publication.
  • A fixed fee, paid before fieldwork. The fee never depends on the grade, and is not refunded for a low one.
  • Every commissioned audit is a Verified audit. It carries the Verified tick, which links to this page and is how we disclose that the firm paid for the audit. Desk audits are never paid for.
  • The firm cannot edit findings or the grade. It can correct facts and publish a reply.
  • Once fieldwork starts, the result is published, whatever the grade.
  • Commissions never touch grades. If TBR earns a commission on a link to a firm, it is disclosed next to the link, and the commission has no bearing on the firm's grade, score or findings.
  • Reviews are separate. Review scores and audit grades are set against separate published methods, and neither an audit fee nor a grade ever changes a review.
  • Partners get no special treatment. Firms with a commercial partnership with TBR are labelled Preferred on their profile, audit report and review and wherever we list or feature them, and are audited under the same rules. They are listed first in tables and lists, but a partnership never changes a grade, a score or a finding.
  • Grades can be withdrawn. A material regulatory action, a failed payout or a misleading use of the badge withdraws a grade immediately, with the reason published.

Verified audits and desk audits

TBR publishes two kinds of audit. Both use this methodology and the same grade scale, and both are published whatever the grade.

ComparedVerified auditDesk audit
Who paysCommissioned and paid for by the firm audited, through Unita MediaNo one: carried out on TBR's own initiative
EvidenceThe firm's own evidence (licences, group structure, audited accounts, banking and safeguarding arrangements, policies), every licence cross-checked against the regulators' own registers, and rigorous testing by our trading experts with live funded accounts, trades and real withdrawalsPublic sources only
Pillars assessedAll 75: Execution & Pricing and Operational Resilience are not assessed
On the report and in listsThe Verified tick beside the firm's name wherever TBR names itLabelled "Desk audit"
LogoThe firm's logo beside its name across TBR while the audit is currentName only
Embeddable badgeYes, linking to the report and showing its own expiryNo

Every commissioned audit is a Verified audit, and every Verified audit is commissioned. The Verified tick is how we disclose that a firm paid for its audit, so reports do not repeat it. The mark describes how the audit was done, never the result: a Verified audit graded C carries the same tick, logo and badge as one graded AAA, and the registry is ordered by score, not by the kind of audit. The fee is agreed with Unita Media, never with the people who grade (see the firewall rule).

Desk audits

A desk audit uses public sources only: regulator registers, enforcement records, court and stock-exchange filings, and the firm's own published documents. No accounts are opened and nothing is tested live, so Execution & Pricing and Operational Resilience are not assessed and do not count towards the grade. People & Community is assessed from public sources in every audit. Desk audits are labelled on the report and the seal, and have no embeddable badge. A firm may commission a Verified audit at any time.

The pillars assessed in a desk audit are scored against these published bands, from the evidence listed in each report:

PillarBandWhat puts a firm there
Regulation & Licensing85 to 100All client-facing entities hold tier-one or tier-two licences; registers match the firm's disclosures; no offshore entity for retail clients.
70 to 84Strong core licences, but the group also onboards retail clients through an offshore entity.
50 to 69A large share of the business runs through offshore entities, or register checks show discrepancies.
25 to 49Retail clients are served only through offshore entities, or a large share of the business runs through a company with no financial licence, or a regulator has suspended or withdrawn a licence in the group in the last eight years, other than at the firm's own request.
below 25No licence from a financial regulator for the services the firm offers.
Corporate Structure & Ownership85 to 100Listed company with audited accounts and regulatory filings in the public domain.
65 to 84Privately held; ownership disclosed; regulated entities identifiable on registers.
40 to 64Ownership or group structure not disclosed, but the companies clients contract with are identifiable.
below 40The firm does not clearly identify the company its clients contract with.
Client Money & Payouts80 to 95Retail clients contract with entities in a compensation scheme, with negative balance protection and segregated client money.
65 to 79Protections apply in the core entities, but an offshore entity offers no compensation scheme.
40 to 64Retail clients contract only with entities outside any compensation scheme, or a regulator has found client money failings.
below 40Public record of payout failures, or client money held by a company that no financial regulator supervises.
People & CommunityWorkplace, up to 5040 for Great Place to Work certification within the last 24 months; 10 more for a place on a national or European Best Workplaces list.
Community, up to 5050 for a sustained, multi-year programme reported by independent media; 30 for a programme reported by the firm with named initiatives, or in its audited accounts; 15 for a single contribution linked to a sponsorship; 0 where none is found.
Conduct & Disclosure85 to 95No public enforcement action in the last eight years.
65 to 84Older or minor enforcement.
40 to 64Recent material enforcement, or regulator proceedings still open.
below 40Repeated material enforcement, a licence suspended or withdrawn as a sanction, or criminal proceedings involving the firm or its owners, all within the last eight years.

Enforcement actions more than eight years old are recorded in the findings but do not affect any score. Regulator warnings and alert lists naming a firm as unauthorised in a country are recorded in the findings but do not by themselves affect the score, because they name many licensed groups that accept clients from those countries. Trading incentives offered by an offshore entity, where they are lawful in that jurisdiction, are recorded in the findings but do not reduce the score. Within a band, the score reflects the number and severity of findings. Absence of a public record is not proof of good conduct, and each report says so in its limitations.

Limits of an audit

An audit is a point-in-time assessment of the evidence available to us. It is not a guarantee of a firm's solvency or conduct, not a regulatory approval, and not investment advice. Each report states its own scope and limitations.