Risk warning:CFDs carry a high risk of rapid losses due to leverage. Only trade what you can afford to lose. Grades and scores are indicative, not a guarantee or financial or legal advice. Read moreCFDs carry a high risk of rapid losses. Grades and scores are indicative, not a guarantee or financial or legal advice. Read more
Broker marketing often mentions compensation schemes. They are real protections, but they cover a narrower risk than many clients assume: the failure of the firm, not the performance of the trades.
What the schemes are for
A compensation scheme pays out when a regulated firm cannot return the money or assets it holds for clients, usually because it has failed. The UK’s Financial Services Compensation Scheme says it may help “if a provider goes out of business and there’s a shortfall in the money or assets it’s holding for you.”
What none of them covers is losing money by trading. The FSCS is explicit: “We can’t accept any claims that are for poor investment performance.” A client who loses their deposit on leveraged trades with a solvent, well-run broker has no claim.
The UK: FSCS
Limit: “up to £85,000 per eligible person, per firm,” for firms that fail after 1 April 2019.
Covers: shortfalls in client money or assets when an authorised firm fails, and some claims for bad advice.
Does not cover: poor investment performance.
Cyprus: the Investor Compensation Fund
Cyprus investment firms, which include many of the brokers serving EU retail clients, are members of CySEC’s Investor Compensation Fund.
Limit: “The maximum amount of compensation per claim is €20,000 and is defined as the lower of 90% of the cumulative covered claims of a covered client and €20,000.”
Covers: non-professional clients of member firms, where the member “has not been able to repay the funds owed to you or return financial instruments to you.”
Payment: within three months of the fund’s decision being communicated to the client.
Side by side
FSCS (UK)
ICF (Cyprus)
Maximum per client, per firm
£85,000
€20,000
Share of the claim paid
100% up to the limit
90%, up to the limit
Covers trading losses
No
No
The EU baseline is set by the Investor Compensation Schemes Directive (97/9/EC), which requires member states’ schemes to cover at least €20,000 per investor. Cyprus pays at that level; individual member states may pay more.
What this means for clients and firms
The entity matters again. Cover attaches to the regulated entity and its scheme membership. A client of a group’s UK company is in the FSCS; a client of the same brand’s Cypriot company is in the ICF; a client onboarded to an offshore entity of the same brand may be in neither.
Compensation is a backstop, not a substitute. The first line of protection is segregation: client money held separately from the firm’s own funds, so it is not available to the firm’s creditors if the firm fails. Compensation pays only for what segregation fails to protect.
For firms, scheme membership is part of the pitch. For a client choosing between entities of the same broker, the difference between £85,000 and €20,000 of cover can decide which entity they want to contract with.
Brazil's securities regulator has unanimously fined FBS Markets Inc. R$2 million and Mitsui Markets Limited R$1.7 million for offering forex and CFDs to Brazilians without authorisation, through Portuguese websites advertising leverage of up to 1:3000 and offering deposits by Pix. It is the CVM's second penalty on a foreign trading platform in ten weeks. We read the ruling: what it found, how the fines were set, and where the other cases stand.
Most of what brokers say about their licences holds up. But seven well-known brands still describe a licence that the register does not show, from a licence Estonia withdrew in April to a St Vincent company that holds none. And in the offshore centres where many international accounts are opened, the licence number on a broker's website often cannot be checked at all.
ASIC wants to keep its CFD leverage limits until 2037 and close three gaps it has found: margin netting, which led 28 firms to refund A$36 million, CFDs over options, on which 85% of retail clients lost money, and crypto-settled products that work like CFDs. Comments close on 9 November.