Summary
StoneX Trading, called City Index until September 2026, is the UK spread betting and CFD brand of Nasdaq-listed StoneX Group. Clients contract with StoneX Financial Ltd, which is authorised by the FCA, segregates client money and is covered by the FSCS, and no offshore company is named. The grade is held back by a 2020 CFTC order that fined the brand’s then UK company USD 250,000 for taking US retail forex clients without registration and for a supervision failure.
- Grade
- AA
- Score
- 77/100
- Fieldwork
- 16 Nov 2026 to 16 Nov 2026
- Findings
- 1 medium1 low6 strength
Scorecard
| Pillar | Weight | Score | Grade |
|---|---|---|---|
| Regulation & Licensing | 19% | AAA | |
| Corporate Structure & Ownership | 14% | AAA | |
| Client Money & Payouts | 19% | AAA | |
| Execution & Pricing | n/a | ||
| Conduct & Disclosure | 14% | A | |
| Operational Resilience | n/a | ||
| People & Community | 5% | B | |
| Overall | 71% | 77 | AA |
The overall score is the weighted average of the assessed pillars, with their weights scaled back up to 100.
This grade summarises the evidence we reviewed up to 16 November 2026. It is not a guarantee of the firm's safety or future conduct, and changes after that date are not reflected. Nothing here is financial or legal advice.
Findings
Regulation & Licensing
86/100StoneX Trading clients, like City Index clients before the relaunch, contract with StoneX Financial Ltd, which the FCA register lists as authorised since 24 March 2006 and as known by the names City Index and StoneX Trading. Neither brand’s website names another company or an offshore company. StoneX retired the City Index brand in the UK on 12 September 2026, and City Index’s former Australian and Singapore pages now redirect to its sister brand FOREX.com.
- StrengthStoneX Financial Ltd (FRN 446717, company 05616586) has been authorised by the FCA since 24 March 2006 and can hold and control client money. The FCA register lists StoneX Trading (since 27 May 2026) and City Index (since 1 March 2021) among the firm’s current trading names, matching the website footers before and after the relaunch.
- StrengthThe April 2026 terms are issued by StoneX Financial Ltd and include an arbitration annex for clients resident in Indonesia, China, Nigeria, Turkey and Egypt. No offshore company is named in City Index’s or StoneX Trading’s footers or terms.
- ObservationOn 9 September 2026 StoneX announced that City Index was relaunching as StoneX Trading with no change to clients’ platforms, accounts or support, and that the City Index UK brand would retire on 12 September 2026. Pages on cityindex.com now redirect to stonex.com, and the former Australian and Singapore pages redirect to FOREX.com.
- ObservationCity Index previously traded in Australia through StoneX Financial Pty Ltd (AFSL 345646, a current ASIC licensee) until at least February 2025, and in Singapore through StoneX Financial Pte. Ltd., which the MAS Financial Institutions Directory lists as a Capital Markets Services licensee. Both companies now serve FOREX.com.
- ObservationCity Index’s former UK company, Gain Capital UK Limited (FRN 113942), named City Index Limited until June 2015 and named in City Index’s footer until at least December 2020, applied to cancel its FCA authorisation on 23 September 2026. A licence given up at the firm’s request is not a sanction. CySEC lists CITYINDEX as an approved trade name of StoneX Europe Ltd, but its approved domains are FOREX.com sites and the City Index website footers we reviewed did not name that company.
Corporate Structure & Ownership
90/100StoneX Financial Ltd is a wholly owned subsidiary of StoneX Group Inc., which is listed on Nasdaq and files audited annual reports with the SEC. The UK company also files its own audited accounts at Companies House.
- StrengthStoneX Group Inc. (Nasdaq: SNEX) filed its annual report on Form 10-K for the year to 30 September 2025, with consolidated accounts audited by KPMG LLP, and named FOREX.com and Cityindex.com as the primary direct channels of its retail forex and CFD business.
- StrengthCompanies House records StoneX Group Inc. as holding 75% or more of StoneX Financial Ltd since 30 June 2021. The company’s accounts for the year to 30 September 2025, filed on 2 February 2026, carry an unmodified opinion from KPMG LLP and describe its Self-Directed division as providing spot forex and CFDs to retail clients.
- ObservationKPMG gave an adverse opinion on StoneX Group’s internal control over financial reporting at 30 September 2025 because of a weakness in how repurchase agreements were netted on the balance sheet; StoneX said the error was corrected before filing and had no effect on earnings, financial position or liquidity, and reported its disclosure controls as effective at 30 June 2026.
Client Money & Payouts
84/100StoneX Trading clients contract with an FCA-regulated company that holds retail client money under the FCA’s client money rules, participates in the FSCS up to £85,000 and gives retail clients negative balance protection. No client of the brand is served by a company outside a compensation scheme.
- StrengthThe April 2026 terms state that client money “must be and will be segregated from our own money” and “will be excluded from the assets available to our creditors” in an insolvency, that eligible clients may claim up to £85,000 from the FSCS, and that a retail client’s aggregate liability for realised losses “cannot exceed your Cash (save in the event of error or fraud)”, except for an account holding only positions opened before the terms’ effective date.
- StrengthStoneX Group reported that StoneX Financial Ltd held regulatory capital of USD 600.3 million against a minimum requirement of USD 490.8 million at 30 June 2026.
- ObservationProfessional clients and eligible counterparties may agree in writing to a title transfer arrangement, under which their money is not held as client money and they would rank as general creditors in an insolvency.
Execution & Pricing
Not assessed in a desk audit. Spreads, slippage and fill quality can only be measured with live accounts.
Conduct & Disclosure
60/100The brand’s companies have one material enforcement action in the last eight years: a 2020 CFTC order against City Index’s then UK company, Gain Capital UK Limited, with a USD 250,000 penalty and USD 241,671 in disgorgement. In 2023 ASIC named the brand’s Australian issuer among CFD issuers that self-reported leverage breaches and remediated clients. Two FSA penalties on City Index Limited, in 2005 and 2011, are more than eight years old.
- MediumOn 8 June 2020 the CFTC ordered Gain Capital UK Limited, the former City Index Limited and City Index’s UK company at the time, to pay a USD 250,000 civil monetary penalty and USD 241,671 in disgorgement to a customer. The order found that from February 2014 to March 2019 the company accepted retail forex customers located in the United States without registering as a retail foreign exchange dealer, and failed to supervise an account managed by an unregistered trading advisor who was defrauding the customer. It acted through Gain Capital Forex.com UK Limited until that company’s business was integrated into it on 6 October 2017, so the same order is recorded in TBR’s FOREX.com audit. The company settled without admitting or denying the findings.
- LowIn November 2023 ASIC named “StoneX Financial Pty Ltd trading as City Index” among seven CFD issuers that self-reported issuing CFDs above the leverage limits in its product intervention order and ran remediation programmes. ASIC described these as possible breaches and did not name the four issuers it required to pay additional compensation; no penalty was imposed.
- ObservationThe FSA fined City Index Limited £490,000 in January 2011 for failing to submit accurate transaction reports for nearly 60% of its reportable transactions between November 2007 and September 2009, and £35,000 in March 2005 over financial promotions for CFDs and spread bets in 2003. These are more than eight years old, so they are recorded here but not scored.
- ObservationNo action was found against StoneX Financial Ltd in FCA records, nor against City Index companies in CySEC board decisions, Brazil’s CVM sanctions data or Ontario Capital Markets Tribunal proceedings. The Reserve Bank of India’s Alert List does not name City Index. The FCA lists clones of StoneX Financial Ltd and Gain Capital UK Limited, including “CTindexforex”, that are not connected with the group.
- ObservationActions against FOREX.com’s US company, GAIN Capital Group LLC, and other StoneX companies that City Index did not use are covered in TBR’s FOREX.com audit and are not scored here.
Operational Resilience
Not assessed in a desk audit. Uptime, incident history and security controls require evidence from the firm or live monitoring.
People & Community
30/100No Great Place to Work certification was found. StoneX’s annual report describes a named “Collective Giving” programme, with a company match for employees’ charitable donations and volunteer hours, and a personal day off for community service.
- ObservationNo Great Place to Work certification was found for StoneX or City Index.
- ObservationThe “Collective Giving” programme is reported by StoneX itself, without amounts; we found no independent reporting. StoneX’s Saracens rugby sponsorship is commercial; StoneX says the deal also makes it lead partner of the Saracens Foundation. A contribution linked to a sponsorship does not raise this score.
Licences verified
Each licence was checked directly against the regulator's public register on the date shown.
| Entity | Regulator | Licence | Checked | Result |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| StoneX Financial Ltd | FCA | FRN 446717 | 16 Nov 2026 | ConfirmedAuthorised since 24 March 2006; can hold and control client money; the register lists StoneX Trading (since 27 May 2026) and City Index (since 1 March 2021) among its six current names; a requirement since 13 October 2025 bars regulated activities in emission allowances for retail clients; two clones listed. |
| Gain Capital UK Limited | FCA | FRN 113942 | 16 Nov 2026 | Confirmed with notesFormer City Index UK company (named City Index Limited until 1 June 2015, company 01761813). Authorised since 1 December 2001, applied to cancel since 23 September 2026; the register’s disciplinary record lists the FSA’s fines on the company as City Index Ltd of 23 March 2005 (£35,000, financial promotions) and 20 January 2011 (£490,000, transaction reporting). |
| StoneX Financial Pty Ltd | ASIC | AFSL 345646 | 16 Nov 2026 | Confirmed with notesCurrent licensee in ASIC’s AFS licensee data of 11 November 2026, licence start 31 May 2010. City Index’s former Australian issuer; the City Index Australia page now redirects to FOREX.com. |
Notes and sources
Sources
- StoneX: Launch of StoneX Trading marks a new era for City Index (9 September 2026)
- StoneX Trading: UK website
- StoneX Trading: strength and security
- StoneX Trading: terms and policies
- StoneX Trading: UK terms and policies, April 2026 (PDF)
- City Index: UK website, archived 31 August 2026
- City Index: UK website, archived 5 December 2020
- City Index: Australia website, archived 10 February 2025
- City Index: Singapore website, archived 8 February 2025
- FCA register: StoneX Financial Ltd
- FCA register: Gain Capital UK Limited
- FCA register: search for City Index
- CySEC register: StoneX Europe Ltd
- ASIC: AFS licensee dataset (data.gov.au)
- CFTC: Release 8174-20, order against Gain Capital UK Limited (8 June 2020)
- CFTC: order, In the Matter of Gain Capital UK Limited, Docket No. 20-16
- ASIC 23-298MR: ASIC oversees more than $17.4 million in compensation to retail investors by OTC derivative issuers
- FSA: Final Notice to City Index Limited, 20 January 2011 (PDF)
- FSA: Final Notice to City Index Limited, 22 March 2005 (PDF)
- StoneX Group Inc.: Form 10-K for the year to 30 September 2025
- StoneX Group Inc.: Form 10-Q for the quarter to 30 June 2026
- Companies House: StoneX Financial Ltd
- Companies House: StoneX Financial Ltd, persons with significant control
- Companies House: StoneX Financial Ltd, filing history
- Companies House: Gain Capital UK Limited (formerly City Index Limited)
- GLEIF: StoneX Financial Ltd
- Reserve Bank of India: Alert List
- Ontario Capital Markets Tribunal: proceedings
- CVM open data: sanctions cases
- MAS: Financial Institutions Directory, StoneX Financial Pte. Ltd.
- MAS: enforcement actions
Evidence and scope
Scope
Desk audit of the StoneX Trading brand, called City Index until September 2026, and its client-facing company, using public sources only: regulator registers and announcements, sanction records, company filings, the global LEI system, and the firm’s own published documents, including archived copies of its website, as available on 16 November 2026. FOREX.com, a sister StoneX brand, is covered by a separate audit. No accounts were opened, nothing was tested live, and the firm was not asked for evidence.
Limitations
Absence of a public enforcement record is not evidence of good conduct. Disciplinary notices of the London Metal Exchange and other exchanges where StoneX Financial Ltd is a member could not be opened and were not assessed. StoneX’s SEC filings were read on its investor relations website, and StoneX Financial Ltd’s scanned accounts were read in part. The share of clients resident outside the UK is not public.
Evidence reviewed
- StoneX press release of 9 September 2026 on the relaunch of City Index as StoneX Trading
- City Index website footers (archived 2018 to September 2026) and StoneX Trading website disclosures
- StoneX Trading UK terms and policies, April 2026
- FCA register entries and register searches; ASIC AFS licensee dataset, November 2026; CySEC register
- CFTC order, In the Matter of Gain Capital UK Limited, Docket No. 20-16, 8 June 2020
- ASIC media release 23-298MR
- FSA final notices to City Index Limited, 2005 and 2011
- StoneX Group Inc. Form 10-K for the year to 30 September 2025 and Form 10-Q for the quarter to 30 June 2026
- Companies House records and accounts of StoneX Financial Ltd and Gain Capital UK Limited; GLEIF records
- Ontario Capital Markets Tribunal, Brazil CVM sanctions data, CySEC board decisions, FFAJ disciplinary list, MAS enforcement actions and Reserve Bank of India Alert List
Version history
- Report published.
Request a re-audit
Staff of StoneX Trading (formerly City Index) can ask us to reopen this audit, for example after correcting a finding or completing remediation. Requests must come from a company email address, and you can attach evidence.
Request a re-audit