Desk audit TBR-A-2026-071

StoneX Trading (formerly City Index)

Independent desk audit of a retail broker, from public sources.

Last updated First published

Current. Valid to 16 November 2027.

TBR DESK AUDIT · PUBLIC SOURCES · AA 77/100

Very strong

Desk audit. TBR carried out this audit on its own initiative, using public sources only. No firm paid for it. No accounts were opened or tested, so Execution & Pricing and Operational Resilience were not assessed and do not count towards the grade. StoneX Trading (formerly City Index) may respond, and any response is published in full. How desk audits are scored. See Verified audits, which our trading experts test hands-on.

Summary

StoneX Trading, called City Index until September 2026, is the UK spread betting and CFD brand of Nasdaq-listed StoneX Group. Clients contract with StoneX Financial Ltd, which is authorised by the FCA, segregates client money and is covered by the FSCS, and no offshore company is named. The grade is held back by a 2020 CFTC order that fined the brand’s then UK company USD 250,000 for taking US retail forex clients without registration and for a supervision failure.

Grade
AA
Score
77/100
Fieldwork
16 Nov 2026 to 16 Nov 2026
Findings
1 medium1 low6 strength

Scorecard

PillarWeightScoreGrade
Regulation & Licensing19%86AAA
Corporate Structure & Ownership14%90AAA
Client Money & Payouts19%84AAA
Execution & Pricingn/aNot assessed: requires live testing
Conduct & Disclosure14%60A
Operational Resiliencen/aNot assessed: requires live testing
People & Community5%30B
Overall71%77AA

The overall score is the weighted average of the assessed pillars, with their weights scaled back up to 100.

This grade summarises the evidence we reviewed up to 16 November 2026. It is not a guarantee of the firm's safety or future conduct, and changes after that date are not reflected. Nothing here is financial or legal advice.

Findings

Licences verified

Each licence was checked directly against the regulator's public register on the date shown.

EntityRegulatorLicenceCheckedResult
StoneX Financial LtdFCAFRN 44671716 Nov 2026ConfirmedAuthorised since 24 March 2006; can hold and control client money; the register lists StoneX Trading (since 27 May 2026) and City Index (since 1 March 2021) among its six current names; a requirement since 13 October 2025 bars regulated activities in emission allowances for retail clients; two clones listed.
Gain Capital UK LimitedFCAFRN 11394216 Nov 2026Confirmed with notesFormer City Index UK company (named City Index Limited until 1 June 2015, company 01761813). Authorised since 1 December 2001, applied to cancel since 23 September 2026; the register’s disciplinary record lists the FSA’s fines on the company as City Index Ltd of 23 March 2005 (£35,000, financial promotions) and 20 January 2011 (£490,000, transaction reporting).
StoneX Financial Pty LtdASICAFSL 34564616 Nov 2026Confirmed with notesCurrent licensee in ASIC’s AFS licensee data of 11 November 2026, licence start 31 May 2010. City Index’s former Australian issuer; the City Index Australia page now redirects to FOREX.com.

Notes and sources

Sources

Evidence and scope

Scope

Desk audit of the StoneX Trading brand, called City Index until September 2026, and its client-facing company, using public sources only: regulator registers and announcements, sanction records, company filings, the global LEI system, and the firm’s own published documents, including archived copies of its website, as available on 16 November 2026. FOREX.com, a sister StoneX brand, is covered by a separate audit. No accounts were opened, nothing was tested live, and the firm was not asked for evidence.

Limitations

Absence of a public enforcement record is not evidence of good conduct. Disciplinary notices of the London Metal Exchange and other exchanges where StoneX Financial Ltd is a member could not be opened and were not assessed. StoneX’s SEC filings were read on its investor relations website, and StoneX Financial Ltd’s scanned accounts were read in part. The share of clients resident outside the UK is not public.

Evidence reviewed

  • StoneX press release of 9 September 2026 on the relaunch of City Index as StoneX Trading
  • City Index website footers (archived 2018 to September 2026) and StoneX Trading website disclosures
  • StoneX Trading UK terms and policies, April 2026
  • FCA register entries and register searches; ASIC AFS licensee dataset, November 2026; CySEC register
  • CFTC order, In the Matter of Gain Capital UK Limited, Docket No. 20-16, 8 June 2020
  • ASIC media release 23-298MR
  • FSA final notices to City Index Limited, 2005 and 2011
  • StoneX Group Inc. Form 10-K for the year to 30 September 2025 and Form 10-Q for the quarter to 30 June 2026
  • Companies House records and accounts of StoneX Financial Ltd and Gain Capital UK Limited; GLEIF records
  • Ontario Capital Markets Tribunal, Brazil CVM sanctions data, CySEC board decisions, FFAJ disciplinary list, MAS enforcement actions and Reserve Bank of India Alert List

Version history

  1. Report published.

Request a re-audit

Staff of StoneX Trading (formerly City Index) can ask us to reopen this audit, for example after correcting a finding or completing remediation. Requests must come from a company email address, and you can attach evidence.

Request a re-audit